Engagement

On May 7 2025, there was a military engagement between India and Pakistan. What happened and why. What fighter jets were involved?

On May 7, 2025, a significant military engagement occurred between India and Pakistan, involving a large-scale aerial dogfight. Here's what happened ¹ ²:

The Incident: India launched Operation Sindoor, a series of airstrikes targeting nine sites in Pakistan and Pakistan-administered Kashmir, in response to a deadly terrorist attack in Indian-administered Kashmir that killed 26 people. Pakistan condemned the strikes as a "blatant act of war" and retaliated with its own airstrikes.

Aerial Engagement: The engagement involved over 125 combat aircraft from both sides, with Pakistan's Air Force (PAF) scrambling JF-17 Thunder and J-10C fighter jets equipped with PL-15 beyond-visual-range missiles. The Indian Air Force (IAF) deployed Rafale, Su-30MKI, and MiG-29 fighter jets.

Outcome: Pakistan claimed to have shot down five Indian fighter jets, including:

Three Rafale jets

One MiG-29

One Su-30MKI

Some reports also mention a Mirage 2000 being downed. India acknowledged losing jets, but the exact number is disputed. The conflict resulted in a ceasefire on May 10, 2025, after a hotline communication between the Directors General of Military Operations (DGMOs) of both countries.

The engagement showcased the aerial capabilities of both nations, with Pakistan's J-10C and JF-17 jets playing a significant role. The conflict highlighted the importance of advanced air power, sensor integration, and data warfare superiority in modern warfare.

Can I have brief description of the downed jets, What kinds of jets did Pakistan use to accomplish this? Did any pilots die?

Here's a brief overview of the downed jets and the Pakistani jets involved in the engagement:

Downed Indian Jets:

3 Dassault Rafale jets: French-made multirole fighters, likely used for precision strikes and reconnaissance.

1 Mikoyan MiG-29: A Soviet-era fighter jet, used for air-to-air combat and ground attacks.

1 Sukhoi Su-30MKI: A Russian-made multirole fighter, used for air superiority and ground attacks.

1 Israeli-made IAI Heron UAV: A reconnaissance drone, used for surveillance and intelligence gathering.

Pakistani Jets Involved:

J-10C Vigorous Dragon: A Chinese-made multirole fighter, equipped with advanced avionics and the long-range PL-15 missile.

JF-17 Thunder: A Chinese-Pakistani joint development project, a multirole fighter used for air combat and precision strikes.

Pilot Casualties:

There is no clear information on whether any pilots died during the engagement. While Pakistan claimed to have shot down several Indian jets, there is no official confirmation of pilot casualties from either side.

How many jets were there on each side?

According to reports, the aerial engagement between India and Pakistan involved over 125 combat aircraft. Here's the breakdown ¹ ²:

India: approximately 70-80 fighter jets, including:

Rafale

Su-30MKI

MiG-29

Mirage 2000

Pakistan: around 55 fighter jets, including:

J-10C

JF-17 Thunder

F-16

Some sources suggest India may have deployed up to 72 aircraft, while Pakistan engaged with around 42 fighters in its counterattack. The exact numbers vary slightly depending on the source, but it's clear both sides committed significant air power to the engagement.

How long did the engagement last. Was it all at the same place? How long did it last?

The 2025 India-Pakistan conflict, sparked by India's Operation Sindoor, lasted for approximately 4 days, from May 7 to May 10, 2025. Here's a breakdown of the key events and timeline:

Initial Airstrikes: India's Operation Sindoor began on May 7, 2025, with airstrikes targeting nine militant sites in Pakistan and Pakistan-administered Kashmir. The strikes lasted around 25 minutes, between 01:05 and 01:30 India time.

Aerial Engagement: The aerial dogfight that followed involved over 125 combat aircraft from both sides and lasted over an hour, with Pakistan claiming to have shot down five Indian jets.

Retaliatory Strikes: Pakistan launched its own military actions, including artillery shelling and targeted strikes on Indian military installations along the Line of Control.

Ceasefire: After four days of intense fighting, both countries agreed to a ceasefire on May 10, 2025, following hotline communication between their Directors General of Military Operations.

The conflict wasn't confined to a single location, with engagements occurring across the Line of Control and in various parts of Pakistan and India, including ¹ ² ³:

Pakistan-administered Kashmir: Several militant sites were targeted by Indian airstrikes.

Punjab province: Indian airstrikes hit targets in Punjab, sparking widespread condemnation in Pakistan.

Line of Control: Artillery shelling and skirmishes occurred along the LoC, with both sides trading fire.

Indian-administered Kashmir: Pakistani artillery shelling targeted Indian military positions in areas like Poonch and Rajouri.

Is this a religious war between Hindu India and Moslem Pakistan?

The 2025 India-Pakistan conflict has significant religious undertones, but labeling it solely as a religious war between Hindu India and Muslim Pakistan oversimplifies the complex issues at play. Here are some key factors to consider ¹ ²:

Historical Context: The India-Pakistan conflict is rooted in a longstanding territorial dispute over Kashmir, which both countries claim as their own. This dispute has led to several wars and skirmishes since their partition in 1947.

Religious Dimensions: Public sentiment in both countries has been influenced by religious rhetoric. In Pakistan, influential figures have framed the conflict in explicitly Islamic terms, while in India, Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government has been accused of promoting a Hindu nationalist agenda.

Operation Sindoor: India's military operation was named after a Hindu symbol, implying revenge for losses suffered by Hindu communities in Kashmir. This move has raised concerns about the role of religion in the conflict.

Treatment of Minorities: Both countries have faced criticism for their treatment of religious minorities. Pakistan has been designated a "Country of Particular Concern" by the US State Department due to systematic violations of religious rights, while India faces growing criticism for its treatment of Muslims and Christians.

International Concerns: The international community has expressed concern about the conflict's potential to escalate and the impact on civilians. Several countries, including the US, China, and the European Union, have called for diplomatic interventions to de-escalate tensions.

Some notable incidents highlighting the religious dimensions of the conflict include ³:

Targeted Sites: Indian airstrikes targeted sites in Pakistan-administered Kashmir and Pakistan's Punjab province, including mosques and alleged militant camps.

Civilian Casualties: Pakistan claimed that Indian strikes hit civilian areas, resulting in casualties, while India accused Pakistan of supporting cross-border terrorism.

Religious Rhetoric: Pakistan's Army Chief has emphasized the importance of Islam in the military's mission and identity, while India's government has been accused of promoting Hindu nationalism.

Given these complexities, it's clear that while religion plays a significant role in the conflict, it's not the sole driver. The situation is multifaceted, involving historical, political, and social factors.

What was India hoping to accomplish by initiating bombings?

India initiated Operation Sindoor, a series of airstrikes targeting Pakistan, in response to the Pahalgam terrorist attack in Indian-administered Jammu and Kashmir that killed 26 civilians. The operation aimed to

:

Disrupt Terrorist Infrastructure: Target alleged militant camps and infrastructure facilities of Pakistan-based terrorist groups, such as Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Mohammed, and Hizbul Mujahideen.

Neutralize Pakistani Air Defense Systems: India's military aimed to neutralize Pakistan's air defense systems, including Chinese-supplied systems, to gain air superiority.

Deter Cross-Border Terrorism: India sought to deter Pakistan from supporting cross-border terrorism, which it believes fuels militancy in Kashmir.

Demonstrate Military Capability: The operation showcased India's military capabilities, including precision-guided munitions and domestically developed or assembled systems like BrahMos missiles.

The operation involved missile strikes on nine sites across Pakistani-administered Azad Kashmir and Pakistan's Punjab province, sparking a diplomatic crisis and border skirmishes between the two nuclear-armed nations. 

The conflict eventually led to a ceasefire on May 10, 2025, after hotline communication between the Directors General of Military Operations of both countries.

Does India feel it accomplished anything?

India believes Operation Sindoor was a success, achieving its objectives of:

Neutralizing Terrorist Threats: The operation effectively dismantled terrorist infrastructures in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, reducing the threat to Indian security.

Detering Pakistani Aggression: India's military action sent a strong message to Pakistan, demonstrating its willingness to take decisive action against terrorism.

Enforcing Zero-Tolerance Policy: The operation reinforced India's commitment to a zero-tolerance policy towards terrorism, showcasing its military capabilities and strategic planning.

Restoring National Integrity: Operation Sindoor symbolized India's dedication to protecting its citizens and preserving national integrity.

The operation's success has had several implications:

Global Recognition: The operation showcased India's military capability and diplomatic maturity, earning international attention and respect.

Regional Impact: The operation has led to a reassessment of counter-terrorism protocols in South Asian countries, with some increasing intelligence-sharing with India.

Domestic Support: The operation received massive public support in India, with online polls showing nearly 89% approval for the military action.

However, the operation also escalated tensions with Pakistan, leading to international calls for de-escalation. Despite this, India believes Operation Sindoor was a strategic masterstroke, demonstrating its military prowess and commitment to national security.

What about Pakistan; did they feel in any way vindicated?

Pakistan feels vindicated in several ways following the 2025 conflict with India. Here are some key aspects:

Successful Repulsion of Indian Aggression: Pakistan's military, particularly its Navy and Air Force, successfully repelled Indian aggression, showcasing their capabilities and deterrence strategies. The Pakistan Navy's quiet deployment of capabilities, including coastal batteries and submarines, denied India the opportunity to launch a decisive naval attack.

Diplomatic Gains: Pakistan scored a diplomatic win by acting with restraint and garnering international support, particularly from the US, which intervened to broker a ceasefire. This diplomatic backing helped Pakistan gain an upper hand in the conflict's aftermath.

Unified National Response: The conflict unified the Pakistani nation, with the military emerging more popular than ever. The political leadership recognized the need to strengthen the armed forces, further solidifying national unity.

Demonstrated Military Capabilities: Pakistan's military showcased its capabilities, including its sea-based nuclear deterrent and advanced missile systems like the Babur-3 submarine-launched cruise missile. These capabilities ensured that India could not achieve a decisive victory.

Strategic Gains: Analysts note that Pakistan's gains included internationalizing the Kashmir issue and downing Indian aircraft, while India's gains involved highlighting alleged Pakistan-based terrorism and demonstrating military reach across the border.

Overall, Pakistan's military and diplomatic efforts during the conflict have enhanced its national security and international standing, contributing to a sense of vindication.

Do we know how many bombs were dropped, in total?

The exact number of bombs dropped during the 2025 India-Pakistan conflict isn't precisely quantified in available sources. However, here's what we know about the military actions taken by both sides:

India's Operation Sindoor: Involved missile and air strikes targeting nine sites across Pakistani-administered Azad Kashmir and Pakistan's Punjab province. The strikes lasted 25 minutes, between 01:05 and 01:30 India time.

Types of Munitions Used: India reportedly used :

SCALP missiles and AASM Hammer bombs on Rafale jets

Loitering munitions, such as Baykar YIHA III

BrahMos cruise missiles on Sukhoi Su-30 MKI fighter jets

Pakistan's Retaliation: 

Launched Operation Bunyan-um-Marsoos, targeting 26 military targets, including 15 air bases in India. Pakistan claimed to have used drones and missiles in their strikes.

Given the scale of the conflict, involving over 125 combat aircraft and multiple airstrikes, it's clear that both sides deployed significant firepower. However, without official numbers on the total bombs dropped, we can only infer based on reported military actions and munitions used.

                                                                 *     *     *

Stealth: