The_Stans

 Decided, last night, it was high time I got clear about those 'stan' countries

of Central Asia. As a first step, got Copilot to produce an overview table:

                                                                     

Asked about mutual intelligibility of languages:

🔍 Mutual Intelligibility Overview

Turkic Languages (Kazakh, Turkmen, Uzbek, Kyrgyz):

These languages share similar grammar, vocabulary, and phonology, so speakers often find it easier to learn or understand one another’s languages.

However, mutual intelligibility is partial, not automatic. For example:

Kazakh and Kyrgyz are more closely related and may be easier to understand between speakers.

Uzbek is somewhat more divergent, especially in pronunciation and vocabulary.

Turkmen is considered more archaic and less mutually intelligible with the others2.

Tajik (Iranian family):

Tajik is not mutually intelligible with the Turkic languages. It’s a variety of Persian and structurally very different.

Russian, widely spoken across the region due to Soviet legacy, often serves as a lingua franca for interethnic communication.

🧠 Fun Linguistic Insight

Think of it like Spanish, Italian, and Portuguese—Turkic languages are cousins, but not twins. You might catch the gist of a conversation, especially with shared roots and loanwords, but full understanding takes effort.

Would you like a breakdown of how these languages evolved or maybe a few example phrases to compare across them

Should Azerbaijan be considered here?

Excellent question—and it opens up a fascinating geopolitical and cultural discussion.

🧭 Is Azerbaijan Part of Central Asia?

Geographically, Azerbaijan is located in the South Caucasus, straddling Eastern Europe and Western Asia. It borders the Caspian Sea, Russia, Georgia, Armenia, Iran—and is not traditionally considered part of Central Asia, which typically includes:

Kazakhstan

Kyrgyzstan

Tajikistan

Turkmenistan

Uzbekistan

However...

🌐 Why Azerbaijan Could Be Considered

Despite its geographic distinction, Azerbaijan shares deep cultural, linguistic, and historical ties with Central Asia:

Language: Azerbaijani is a Turkic language, closely related to Turkmen, Uzbek, and Kazakh.

Religion: Predominantly Muslim (Shia majority), like many Central Asian nations.

Soviet Legacy: Like the "Stans," Azerbaijan was part of the USSR and shares post-Soviet political and economic challenges.

Strategic Alliances: Azerbaijan actively participates in regional cooperation frameworks with Central Asian countries, such as:

The Turkey-Azerbaijan-Kazakhstan and Turkey-Azerbaijan-Uzbekistan trilateral platforms2

Energy and transport corridors like the Middle Corridor, linking China to Europe via Central Asia and the Caucasus

🧠 Bottom Line

While not geographically Central Asian, Azerbaijan is often included in broader regional discussions—especially in terms of energy, trade, and cultural diplomacy. So yes, depending on the context (especially political or economic), Azerbaijan can be considered alongside the Central Asian countries.

Would you like me to add Azerbaijan to the comparison table we built earlier? I can show how it stacks up in terms of population, GDP, language, and more.

                                                                         

🧭 Azerbaijan shares strong cultural and linguistic ties with the Turkic-speaking Central Asian nations, especially Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. However, its Shia-majority religious profile and South Caucasus geography set it apart in key ways.

Would you like to explore how these countries collaborate in energy, trade, or regional security next? Or maybe dive into their historical connections through the Silk Road?

                                                                        *     *     *

How come Russia escaped Muslim influence?

Russia didn’t exactly “escape” Muslim influence—it’s more accurate to say that its relationship with Islam has been complex, evolving, and regionally varied over centuries.

🕌 Historical Overview of Islam in Russia

Early Encounters: Islam reached parts of what is now Russia as early as the 7th–10th centuries, especially in the Volga region and the North Caucasus. The Volga Bulgars converted to Islam in 922, long before Russia became a unified Christian state.

Tsarist Strategy: As the Russian Empire expanded into Muslim-majority areas (like Tatarstan, Dagestan, and Chechnya), it often used a mix of co-optation and control. The empire recognized Islamic institutions but also regulated them tightly, integrating Muslim elites into the imperial bureaucracy.

Soviet Suppression: Under the USSR, religion—including Islam—was aggressively suppressed. Thousands of mosques were closed, clerics were imprisoned or executed, and religious education was banned. This created a generational gap in religious knowledge and practice.

Post-Soviet Revival: After 1991, Islam saw a resurgence, especially in regions like Chechnya, Tatarstan, and Bashkortostan. However, this revival has been met with suspicion and control from the central government, especially when linked to political dissent or separatism1.

🧭 Why Russia Isn’t a Muslim-Majority Country

Core Ethnic Identity: The heartland of Russia—centered around Moscow and St. Petersburg—has historically been Slavic and Orthodox Christian, which shaped the national identity.

Geopolitical Orientation: Russia’s expansion was often westward and northward, toward Europe and Siberia, rather than into the Islamic heartlands of Central Asia or the Middle East.

Religious Policy: Both Tsarist and Soviet regimes promoted Orthodox Christianity or atheism, marginalizing Islam as a regional or minority religion.

🧠 Today’s Landscape

Russia is home to over 14 million Muslims, making Islam the second-largest religion in the country. Regions like Chechnya, Dagestan, and Tatarstan have vibrant Muslim communities. The Kremlin now balances strategic engagement with Muslim leaders while maintaining tight control over religious expression.

So, Russia didn’t escape Muslim influence—it absorbed it, reshaped it, and continues to negotiate its place within a multiethnic, multireligious federation.

Would you like to explore how Islam compares to Orthodox Christianity in Russia today, or how Muslim-majority regions interact with Moscow politically?

                                                                   *     *     *

In what country is Chechnya?

Chechnya is a federal republic within Russia. It’s located in the North Caucasus region, near the border with Georgia, and not far from the Caspian Sea.

While Chechnya declared independence in the early 1990s following the collapse of the Soviet Union, Russia reasserted control after two brutal wars. Today, Chechnya is governed as part of the Russian Federation, with its own local government but under Moscow’s authority.

Its capital is Grozny, and the region is known for its mountainous terrain, strong cultural identity, and complex political history. If you're curious, I can dive into the Chechen wars, its current leadership, or how it fits into Russia’s broader strategy in the Caucasus.

                                                                                       

                                               source: Britannica

The war against Chechnya brought Vladimir Putin to celebrity. Explain that to me...

Absolutely—Putin’s rise to prominence is tightly intertwined with the Second Chechen War, and it’s one of the most pivotal chapters in modern Russian political history.

🔥 The Chechen Conflict as Putin’s Launchpad

In the late 1990s, Russia was in turmoil:

The First Chechen War (1994–1996) had ended in a humiliating stalemate for Russia.

Chechnya remained unstable, and in 1999, Islamist militants from Chechnya invaded neighboring Dagestan, prompting a new military response.

Around the same time, a series of apartment bombings in Russian cities killed hundreds. The Kremlin blamed Chechen terrorists, though the true origins remain controversial.

🚀 Putin’s Meteoric Rise

At this moment of crisis:

Boris Yeltsin, Russia’s ailing president, appointed Vladimir Putin—then a relatively unknown former KGB officer—as Prime Minister in August 1999.

Putin responded to the Chechen crisis with ruthless military force, ordering the bombing of Grozny, Chechnya’s capital, and launching a full-scale invasion.

His tough stance and no-nonsense rhetoric—including his infamous vow to “wipe out terrorists in the outhouse”—struck a chord with a Russian public desperate for stability and strength.

By December 31, 1999, Yeltsin abruptly resigned, and Putin became acting president. His approval ratings soared, largely due to his handling of the war2.

🧱 Building the “Power Vertical”

The war gave Putin:

A nationalist platform to consolidate power.

Justification to centralize authority, suppress dissent, and control media.

A chance to rebrand Russia as a strong, unified state after years of post-Soviet chaos.

As one analysis put it, Chechnya became the pretext for constructing Putin’s “power vertical”—a system of top-down control that still defines Russian governance today.

In short, the Second Chechen War wasn’t just a military campaign—it was a political crucible that transformed Putin from a bureaucrat into a symbol of Russian resurgence. If you're curious, I can walk you through how this shaped his long-term strategy or how Chechnya evolved under Moscow’s grip.

But today, President Putin has a Chechen ally. Tell me about that...

Yes—today, Ramzan Kadyrov, the leader of Chechnya, is one of Vladimir Putin’s most loyal and controversial allies.

🧨 From Rebel Roots to Kremlin Ally

Ramzan Kadyrov is the son of Akhmad Kadyrov, a former separatist mufti who switched sides during the Second Chechen War and aligned with Moscow.

After Akhmad was assassinated in 2004, Putin appointed Ramzan as Chechnya’s president in 2007, when he was just 30 years old.

Since then, Ramzan has ruled Chechnya with an iron grip, building a cult of personality, suppressing dissent, and reconstructing Grozny into a gleaming capital.

🤝 Putin & Kadyrov: A Symbiotic Relationship

Kadyrov calls himself “Putin’s foot soldier” and has pledged unwavering loyalty to the Kremlin.

In return, Putin has given Kadyrov broad autonomy and massive federal funding, allowing him to run Chechnya as a quasi-feudal domain.

Their alliance is built on mutual dependence: Kadyrov ensures stability in a historically rebellious region, while Putin provides protection and legitimacy.

🪖 Role in Ukraine & Beyond

Kadyrov has sent thousands of Chechen fighters—known as Kadyrovtsy—to support Russia’s war in Ukraine2.

He’s described the invasion as a “holy war”, blending nationalist and religious rhetoric to rally support.

His forces have also operated in Syria and Georgia, acting as Kremlin proxies.

⚠️ Controversies & Global Impact

Kadyrov is accused of serious human rights abuses, including torture, extrajudicial killings, and persecution of LGBTQ+ individuals.

Despite this, he maintains influence in Muslim-majority countries, positioning himself as a bridge between Russia and the Islamic world.

In many ways, Kadyrov represents the Chechen paradox: once a symbol of resistance, now a pillar of Putin’s centralized power. Their alliance is both strategic and deeply personal—Chechnya’s fate is tightly bound to the Kremlin’s ambitions.

Would you like to explore how Kadyrov’s influence extends beyond Russia, or how Chechnya’s internal politics have evolved under his rule?

                                                                   *     *     *

Has Azerbaijan ever been under communist control?

Yes—Azerbaijan was under communist control for over 70 years as part of the Soviet Union.

🛠️ Timeline of Communist Rule in Azerbaijan

1918–1920: Azerbaijan briefly gained independence as the Azerbaijan Democratic Republic (ADR)—the first secular democratic republic in the Muslim world.

April 1920: The Red Army invaded Baku, ending the ADR and establishing the Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic (Azerbaijan SSR)2.

1920–1991: Azerbaijan remained a Soviet republic, governed by the Communist Party and tightly controlled from Moscow. During this time:

Forced collectivization and Stalinist purges devastated the population.

Over 120,000 people were deported, especially during the 1940s.

Baku became a major center for oil production, contributing heavily to the Soviet economy.

Cultural and religious expression was suppressed, and national identity was tightly managed.

1991: Following the collapse of the USSR, Azerbaijan declared independence and began transitioning away from communism.

🧭 Legacy Today

Although Azerbaijan is now an independent republic, the legacy of Soviet rule still influences its political structure, economy, and civil society. The country has struggled with democratic reforms and retains authoritarian tendencies, shaped in part by its communist past.

Would you like to explore how Azerbaijan’s post-Soviet transition compares to other former Soviet republics, or how its oil wealth has shaped its modern politics?